Each month
in our "Secrets To Their Success" private members' web site,
we interview e-business people who are making fantastic profits
with their online businesses. We ask them for the details
of how they've come to be so successful -- what exactly their
secrets are, what tools they've used, etc. And we find out
some interesting things...
A number
of these people have recently reported having great success
with Google AdWords
Select. In fact, in one of the interviews we did last
month, our interviewee told us he is generating an average
of 13,000 unique visitors per day by having
keyword listings on both Google AdWords and Overture.com.
Google AdWords
Select is the pay-per-click side of the search engine giant
we all know as Google. Just a few months old, Google AdWords
Select is an offshoot of its cost-per-impression sister Google
AdWords, which has been available for a little longer.
An ad
placed with Google AdWords Select shows up in a colored box
on the right side of the Google search results page, combining
free (editorial) content with paid advertising. It's another
form of pay-per-click advertising that, done right, has proven
to effectively generate traffic.
The ads
are extremely high in visibility, set off from the main text
in Google's familiar pages that attract over 20 million
unique visitors per month. Your URL can appear on the
first page of search results without all the hassles
of search engine submission and optimization... and you don't
pay unless viewers click!
Sound
like the ideal advertising set-up? Well, it's been very profitable
for some... But let's have a look at what exactly Google AdWords
Select offers, how it differs from competing sites in its
industry, and how you can use it to your benefit.
Because
Overture has dominated the pay-per-click industry almost unrivaled
until now, I'll use it as a point of comparison to examine
the merits of Google AdWords Select.
The main
difference between the two programs is the way in which their
ads are listed -- Google's are highlighted alongside the regular
Google search results, and Overture's appear as regular
search results. However, there are five other points of difference
that are very important to understand...
1. Pricing
The pricing
structures for each are very different:
When you
sign up for Overture,
you must pay a $50 deposit that is applied to your monthly
click-throughs and your monthly "spend" (you must spend a
minimum of $20 per month in click-throughs; if you don't,
the money will be subtracted from your deposit). The minimum
bid amount is 5 cents.
In Google
AdWords Select, you must pay a $5 non-refundable fee that
is not put toward your click-through fees. There is no monthly
minimum to pay. The minimum bid is said to be 5 cents, but
this is not the case for all keywords -- in fact, bidding
on popular keywords tends to be more expensive here.
2.
Bidding Your Way to the Top
If you want
to bid on the term "baseball bats" in Overture, you could
run a query in their View
Bids tool to determine that (at the time of writing) the
number-one position has a maximum bid of $1.18 per click.
You'd have to beat that bid to get the coveted position.
In Google
AdWords, there is no "View Bids" or equivalent tool; you don't
have any access to the amounts other advertisers are bidding.
What you can do is fiddle with the numbers in the "Traffic
Estimator Tool" (which you'll find when you go to set
up your ad) to find out how much you'll have to pay to
get a top position with your keyword.
By testing
different amounts in the Traffic Estimator, we found that
the minimum bids changed according
to the popularity of each keyword. A minimum bid for the keywords
"baseball bats" in Google AdWords Select requires (at the
time of writing) $0.40 per click and ranks your ad fifth.
This is the same as the bid for the number-five position in
Overture.
But to attain
the number-one position in Google AdWords Select, you'll have
to cough up a hefty $2.60 per click, while the ace spot in
Overture goes for a maximum bid of $1.18.
3.
Keeping Your Bid Costs Low
When Google
AdWords Select first came out, it got an edge on its competition
by creating the "AdWords Discounter." This tool automatically
keeps your bid one penny ahead of the competition, up to your
stated maximum amount, thereby accomplishing two very important
tasks:
- It keeps
you from having to monitor your bids and your competition
all day every day, and
- If your
next closest competitor lowers his or her bid, your bid
will automatically be lowered to only a penny over the lesser
amount. This prevents "bid gaps," which occur when a wide
margin exists between one bid and the next lowest bid, causing
the higher bidder to spend unnecessary money.
Since then,
Overture has taken the hint and has implemented a similar
tool, referred to as its "Auto Bidding" tool. Be careful,
however, to make sure you sign up for this service in Overture
-- it does not happen automatically, and you may be caught
paying much more than you need to!
Allow me
to illustrate: In our search on "baseball bats," the top bid
was, as mentioned, $1.18. The next highest bid, however, was
$0.65! That means the unfortunate soul in the fortunate position
of being number one could be saving 52 cents per click!
...And if
this calculation is taken into consideration, and if we drop
the number-one listing's bid amount to $0.66 cents (all it
needs to be), it means that the number-one spot in Google
AdWords Select costs four times more than in Overture for
this particular keyword.
I know
that sounds expensive, but Google's approach to advertising
could mean an excellent return on investment on your ad (depending
on your ad, of course!) -- so although you pay more, you could
profit more as well.
| Note:
If you're not sure how much is too much to bid on the
keywords you want, take a look at issue
54 of our newsletter, where we discuss how to determine
the dollar value of your customers -- if you bid over
this amount, you could end up losing money. |
The only
way to really determine both the value and the volume
of your traffic from your Overture ad as compared to your
Google AdWords Select ad is by tracking your advertising.
Each program will allow you to assign a tracking URL to your
ad -- a URL that contains a special identifier so that you
can tell which ad is pulling the most response from where
and ensure that it is generating enough revenue to be worth
the cost of advertising.
Google
AdWords Select makes it very easy to create a tracking URL
when you initially set up your account. In Overture it's not
quite as easy, but they'll tell you what to do at:
http://www.overture.com/d/USm/learning/track_howb.jhtml
Your
viewers won't see this URL -- they'll click on your web site
link and be redirected through your tracking ID. We personally
track all of our advertising with our affiliate software --
AssocTRAC.
It's the easiest and most effective way we've found to keep
an eye on our ads and ensure that they're turning the profit
we expect.
4.
Listing Position
Your
listing position is more than just a matter of catching viewers'
attention -- in both Overture and Google AdWords Select, a
top-three listing can dramatically increase the exposure of
your ad.
Overture's
massive reach is enabled not only by its well-known name,
but also by its partnerships with:
- Yahoo
- Ask
Jeeves
- InfoSpace
- MSN
- AltaVista
- Netscape
But
Google AdWords is no shrinking violet either; its partners
include:
- America
Online
- Earthlink
- Sympatico/Lycos
Your
ad is guaranteed listings on all partners' sites only if it
appears in the top three listings for your search term. So
how do you achieve this position?
In Overture,
the process is simple: the more you pay, the better your listing.
If you outbid all the other people competing for your keywords,
you'll attain a top listing in the pages of search results.
Simple as that.
In Google
AdWords Select, the listing process is very different, and
is unique in the pay-per-click industry. First of all, Google
AdWords ads are listed at the top right of Google's search
result pages. This means that your ad shows up in a prominent
position alongside (but set apart from) Google's editorial
(unpaid) listings.
Secondly,
and most surprisingly, your ranking is determined both by
how much you bid and by how many click-throughs your
ad generates. The more you bid, the better your chances of
attaining a top ranking are -- but if your ad doesn't perform,
it just slides on down the rankings.
Google's
argument for this kind of approach is that ads that perform
are (obviously) of more interest to viewers, so this kind
of system creates the best quality results for users. Google
also maintains that performance-based placement keeps competitors
from getting locked out of top positions by those with more
money to spend.
But the
problem with Google's payment-plus-popularity placement system
is that it can be very difficult to figure out exactly where
your ad will appear. And if you're paying the top price for
the top listing but not actually getting the top position
on Google's results page, you'll not only be a little disgruntled
-- you'll also have to do some work on your ad to try to get
the response you're aiming for.
5. Choosing Keywords
Back to
keywords -- but let's take a step back from bidding on them
and talk about the process of choosing them in the first place...
Both Overture
and Google AdWords supply tools to help you determine which
keywords would be best for you to use. However, Overture provides
a much more extensive and useful range of tools.
Google's
"AdWords Keyword Suggestion Tool" does give you a list of
synonyms and similar phrases for your keyword. For example,
when I punched in "Baseball Bats" I got a list of 20 related
terms.
However,
when I entered "Baseball Bats" into Overture's "Search Term
Suggestion Tool," I got a list of 99 related terms, PLUS how
many times each of those terms has been searched in the last
month. Flip over to the "View Bids" tool to determine how
much is being bid on these terms, and your bidding strategy
is underway.
But if you
want to get a good pay-per-click listing on Google, there's
no reason why you can't use Overture
to get
a feel for which terms are most searched, and
which are available at low cost (you can do this for free
and without committing to anything with Overture), then
use these terms to create your ad in Google AdWords Select.
Or, better
yet, use the more comprehensive tools offered by WordTracker
-- the free version will give you search numbers
and bidding amounts from AltaVista, while the paid version
compiles results from the top 24 search engines, directories,
and pay-per-click engines, including Google. This is the best
way to find those overlooked keywords and misspellings that
your competition hasn't noticed... and that you can capitalize
on at a very low cost.
Final Thoughts:
The success
experienced by our Secrets
To Their Success interviewees who used Google AdWords
Select is a good indicator of what you can do with this somewhat
elusive form of pay-per-click advertising.
Google has a very good reputation and is widely used
as a search tool with quality (unpaid) listings, and you just
can't miss the "sponsored links" listed down the right column
of the page.
It is perhaps
this degree of visibility that has made such a difference
to those advertisers who have generated a great response with
Google AdWords Select.
And
now that you know how to use Google AdWords Select to achieve
the best results possible, you can start getting in on some
of Google's masses of traffic. To maximize the performance
of your ad, make sure to...
- Choose
the keywords you bid on very carefully. Try to choose keywords
that are frequently searched by your target market but that
are not being bid on by as many of your competitors.
- Write
an effective ad (see issue
65 of our newsletter for tips on how to make the best
use of the space you have).
- Monitor
your bid position. Whenever possible, make sure you rank
in the top 3 listings as this will get your ad the highest
exposure.
- Track
your results and make adjustments and improvements based
on what you learn.
Learning
the search engine game is a trying and time-consuming lesson,
and a start-up e-business may not have the time or the resources
to undertake the arduous task of getting a good ranking. But
if you can choose your keywords carefully and find the most
attractive bid amounts available, you can bid your way to
the top of the search results pages without blowing your budget.